The scores given in this year’s and last year's Safest City Award rankings were calculated using the same methodology and are comparable. The population threshold is also the same at 75,000. However, a city's ranking is not necessarily comparable because nine cities are in this year's survey that were not considered last year. In addition, seven cities that reported data last year did not this year and thus were not considered. This change in the universe of cities makes a direct comparison of rankings inaccurate.
Below is a table showing the ten cities with the greatest improvement in their scores and the ten cities with the largest decline in their scores. It should be noted that this chart shows just the raw change in score. Cities with scores well above the national average (meaning higher crime) have the most room for improvement and tend to be the ones with the largest swings up and down in scoresCities with a score of zero have crime that averages out to the national average. Cities with scores below zero (i.e. a negative number) have crime below the national average. Cities with scores above zero have crime higher than the national average.
Most Improved Cities | Cities With Largest Declines | ||||||||
Scores: |
This Year | Last Year | Change |
Scores: |
This Year | Last Year | Change | ||
1 |
Camden, NJ |
298.30 |
407.49 |
109.19 |
1 |
Compton, CA |
304.11 |
210.16 |
-93.95 |
2 |
Canton, OH |
97.25 |
178.66 |
81.41 |
2 |
Youngstown, OH |
248.54 |
165.66 |
-82.88 |
3 |
Savannah, GA |
72.50 |
130.88 |
58.38 |
3 |
Oakland, CA |
248.81 |
191.24 |
-57.57 |
4 |
Wichita Falls, TX |
51.32 |
95.19 |
43.87 |
4 |
Birmingham, AL |
281.71 |
224.18 |
-57.53 |
5 |
Tampa, FL |
119.38 |
163.13 |
43.75 |
5 |
Yakima, WA |
106.02 |
50.55 |
-55.47 |
6 |
Richmond, VA |
226.94 |
266.56 |
39.62 |
6 |
Federal Way, WA |
84.35 |
31.17 |
-53.18 |
7 |
Jackson, MS |
144.48 |
180.73 |
36.25 |
7 |
Longview, TX |
107.27 |
55.60 |
-51.67 |
8 |
Atlanta, GA |
210.69 |
246.86 |
36.17 |
8 |
Norfolk, VA |
91.22 |
41.26 |
-49.96 |
9 |
Columbia, SC |
97.06 |
132.26 |
35.20 |
9 |
Trenton, NJ |
233.29 |
184.08 |
-49.21 |
10 |
Miami, FL |
143.45 |
178.27 |
34.82 |
10 |
North Charleston, SC |
198.77 |
150.13 |
-48.64 |
This is the thirteenth year that Morgan Quitno has issued the Safest City and Safest Metropolitan Area rankings. The first year, we only ranked the nation’s 100 largest cities. The second year, we looked at cities of more than 100,000 but used a different method to determine the rankings. The third and fourth years, the universe of cities remained the same (100,000+ population), but the study was done in partnership with Money Magazine using a slightly different methodology. In 1998, we lowered the population threshold for cities to 75,000 or more and adopted the current methodology. Therefore, this most recent survey is only comparable with surveys conducted since 1998.
Because of interest in the previous years' rankings we have left those pages on our website. Click below to go to those pages. To return to this year's ranking you will need to either press your "Back" button in your browser or return to our home page and click there on the connection to our new press release.